Nebiyat Zetselot
Emperor Menelik II of Ethiopia remains one of the most influential and transformative figures in Ethiopian and African history. His reign, which spanned from 1889 to 1913, was marked by remarkable kindness, democratic leadership, modernization, and an unwavering commitment to his people. Despite these commendable qualities, there has been a concerted effort—especially by some Ethiopian elites and external forces—to tarnish his legacy, particularly due to his victory at the Battle of Adwa, which thwarted European colonization of Ethiopia.
This article seeks to explore the complexities surrounding Menelik’s legacy, the efforts to defame him, and the broader implications of such campaigns for Ethiopia and Africa.
1. Menelik II’s Kindness and Mercy: A True Demonstration of Leadership
One of the hallmarks of Menelik II’s reign was his extraordinary kindness and compassion, even toward his enemies. A striking example of this is the way he treated King Teklehaimanot of Gojam, a rival whom he had captured in battle. During a conflict between their respective forces, Menelik took King Teklehaimanot prisoner. However, unlike many monarchs of the time who would have executed or severely punished their captives, Menelik granted the king amnesty.
Not only did Menelik provide King Teklehaimanot with medical treatment for his wounds, but he also offered him kind hospitality and allowed him to regain his position as the ruler of Gojam. In doing so, Menelik demonstrated not only magnanimity but a level of mercy that was rare, even by the standards of the time. It is difficult to find many other examples of such compassionate leadership, particularly in the context of imperial warfare.
This act of mercy underscores Menelik’s view of leadership as being rooted in empathy and a genuine concern for the well-being of both allies and enemies alike. His treatment of King Teklehaimanot stands in stark contrast to the often brutal tactics employed by other leaders of the period, whether in Africa or Europe.
2. Inclusivity and Empowerment: A Democratic Leader Ahead of His Time
Menelik II was not only kind, but also a highly inclusive and democratic leader. He is known for empowering people from diverse social, religious, ethnic, and geographic backgrounds to serve in key positions within his government. This approach was highly unusual for the time, particularly in a continent where many monarchs ruled with absolute authority, often favoring one ethnic or social group over others.
Menelik believed in delegating responsibility, empowering his officials to independently carry out their duties. His inclusive approach to governance helped foster a sense of unity and national identity in Ethiopia, despite its ethnic and regional diversity. By embracing diversity in his administration, Menelik laid the groundwork for a more unified and cohesive Ethiopia, even as the country faced internal and external challenges.
Moreover, Menelik’s democratic vision extended to his treatment of his wife, Empress Taytu. Unlike many monarchs who relegated their wives to symbolic or ceremonial roles, Menelik fully recognized Empress Taytu’s abilities and allowed her to take an active part in both domestic and political affairs. She played an essential role during times of peace and war, advising Menelik on matters of governance and military strategy. This was a radical and progressive approach for the time, signaling Menelik’s belief in empowering capable leaders regardless of gender.
3. Radical Innovation and Modernization
Emperor Menelik II was also a king of progress and innovation. At a time when Ethiopia was still largely agrarian and isolated, Menelik sought to modernize his country and place it on par with the rapidly industrializing powers of Europe. His reign saw the introduction of modern schools, telecommunications, hospitals, and hotels to Ethiopia. He also oversaw the construction of Ethiopia’s first railway, linking Addis Ababa to the port city of Djibouti.
This railway was not just a symbol of modernity but a crucial infrastructure project that facilitated trade, communication, and the movement of people. It represented Menelik’s foresight in understanding that Ethiopia’s survival as an independent nation depended on its ability to modernize and compete in an increasingly connected world. Similarly, Menelik introduced the automobile to Ethiopia, laying the foundation for Ethiopia’s transportation infrastructure.
In short, Menelik’s reign marked a period of rapid modernization, ensuring that Ethiopia could maintain its sovereignty in a world increasingly dominated by colonial powers.
4. The Battle of Adwa: A Symbol of Resistance Against Colonization
Emperor Menelik II’s most celebrated moment came in 1896, when he led Ethiopian forces to a resounding victory against the invading Italian army at the Battle of Adwa. This victory was not only a military triumph but also a political and symbolic one. It marked the first time an African nation had successfully defeated a European colonial power, and it sent shockwaves through Europe.
The Battle of Adwa was a turning point in the Scramble for Africa, as it demonstrated that African nations could resist European imperialism and maintain their sovereignty. This victory became a source of immense pride not only for Ethiopians but for all Africans. Menelik’s victory was celebrated across the continent as a beacon of hope in the struggle for independence.
However, this very success would also make Menelik a target for defamation. His triumph at Adwa disrupted European colonial ambitions in Africa and was viewed as a significant setback for the imperialist powers. As a result, European nations, particularly Italy and Britain, sought ways to undermine Menelik’s reputation.
5. The Defamation Campaign: Historical Context and Motivations
The most plausible explanation for the defamation of Menelik II’s legacy lies in his challenge to the colonial agenda. Menelik’s victory at Adwa threatened European powers’ plans to colonize the continent, and this was a major source of European frustration. In the wake of Adwa, European powers began to craft negative narratives about Menelik’s leadership.
These defamation campaigns were not confined to European powers. In Ethiopia, some intellectuals and political elites, influenced by Western ideas and colonial narratives, began to echo these negative portrayals of Menelik. These elites were often incentivized through financial rewards, education, or social status to promote the interests of colonial powers, consciously or unconsciously aligning themselves with the European narrative.
This phenomenon was not unique to Ethiopia; throughout Africa, colonial powers successfully co-opted local elites to propagate colonial ideas and undermine indigenous leaders who posed a threat to European control. In Menelik’s case, these elites, possibly seeking favor with colonial powers or driven by their own political ambitions, sought to frame him as a cruel or invader king—claims that had little basis in reality.
Interestingly, none of Menelik’s predecessors—Emperor Tewodros or Emperor Yohannes—faced the same level of scrutiny, despite their more controversial actions. Tewodros, for example, conducted internal wars during the power struggles of the “Zemene Mesafint” (Era of Princes), leading to the deaths of many citizens. Similarly, Yohannes IV sought to forcibly convert Muslims to Christianity, an act that led to violent conflicts. These actions, though brutal, were not subject to the same level of defamation that Menelik experienced, suggesting that the motivations behind the attacks on Menelik’s legacy were tied to geopolitical factors.
6. Conclusion: The Importance of Reclaiming Menelik II’s Legacy
The defamation of Emperor Menelik II’s legacy is an issue that deserves careful intellectual discourse. While there is no denying the complexities of his reign, Menelik II remains a leader whose kindness, democratic principles, and innovative vision have left a profound impact on Ethiopia and Africa as a whole. His leadership not only secured Ethiopia’s independence but also set the stage for the modernization of the country.
The efforts to undermine Menelik’s legacy must be understood within the broader context of European colonialism and the ideological battles of the time. Menelik’s victory at Adwa was a major blow to colonialism, and the defamation campaigns that followed can be seen as part of a larger effort to discredit African resistance to European imperialism.
For Ethiopians and Africans today, reclaiming Menelik II’s legacy is not just about restoring the reputation of an individual leader but about recognizing the broader historical forces that shaped Africa’s resistance to colonization. Menelik’s story is one of courage, mercy, and vision—a story that continues to inspire those fighting for justice, sovereignty, and dignity in the face of external and internal challenges.
Editor’s note : Views in the article do not necessarily reflect the views of borkena.com
__
Subscribe to support : https://borkena.com/2025/01/09/support-borkena-platform/
Join our Telegram Channel : t.me/borkena
Like borkena on Facebook
Add your business to Ethiopian Business Listing / Ethiopian Business Directory
Join the conversation. Follow us on X (Formerly Twitter) @zborkena to get the latest Ethiopian News updates regularly. Subscribe to YouTube channel To share information or for submission, send e-mail to info@borkena.com